November 2, 2026
Wolframite vs scheelite: what tungsten buyers need to know
Wolframite vs scheelite: how the two tungsten concentrates differ in chemistry, processing, impurities and contract terms, and what buyers should check.
Almost all tungsten concentrate traded today is one of two minerals: wolframite or scheelite. Both are sold on their WO₃ content and both end up as APT, oxide, powder or ferrotungsten. But the comparison of wolframite vs scheelite matters to a buyer, because the two behave differently in the mill, in the converter and in the contract. This explainer sets out the differences that affect what you buy and what you pay.
Two minerals, two chemistries
Wolframite is an iron-manganese tungstate, (Fe,Mn)WO₄. It is a series rather than a single mineral: the iron-rich end is called ferberite and the manganese-rich end hübnerite. In the trade it is often called "black ore".
Scheelite is a calcium tungstate, CaWO₄, sometimes called "white ore".
The US Geological Survey gives the tungsten content of the pure minerals as about 63.9% W for scheelite and about 60.5–60.8% W for the wolframite end members. In practice, both are upgraded into concentrates that usually grade 65% WO₃ or more, and both are priced per metric tonne unit (MTU) of WO₃. Our explainer on concentrate pricing covers how that unit works.
Where each is found
The two minerals form in different geological settings. Wolframite is typically the main tungsten mineral in quartz vein and stockwork deposits, often alongside cassiterite (tin ore). Scheelite is typically the main mineral in skarn deposits, where hot fluids have reacted with limestone. A review of tungsten resources published in 2023 estimates that scheelite is present in around two-thirds of known tungsten deposits.
This has a practical consequence for origin: the deposit type largely decides which concentrate a mine sells. Rwanda's Nyakabingo mine, for example, produces wolframite concentrate at 65–70% WO₃.
How each is concentrated
The physical properties of the two minerals drive how a mine recovers them, and this affects the impurity profile of the concentrate a buyer receives.
- Wolframite is dense and weakly magnetic. It is usually recovered by gravity separation (jigs, spirals, shaking tables), followed by magnetic separation to separate it from cassiterite and other heavy minerals. Gravity and magnetic methods lose efficiency on very fine particles.
- Scheelite is also dense but is not magnetic, so magnetic separation does not work. Coarse scheelite can be recovered by gravity, but fine scheelite is usually recovered by flotation. Scheelite flotation is difficult, because calcite, fluorite and apatite in the ore have similar surface properties.
Both minerals are brittle and break easily during grinding. Recovery rates for tungsten ores vary widely, from about 60% to 90%.
Impurities: the line-by-line check
Because the minerals form in different settings, they tend to carry different impurities.
- Wolframite from vein deposits often occurs with tin (cassiterite), and vein ores can also contain sulphides and arsenic-bearing minerals such as arsenopyrite. Tin and arsenic are typical elements for buyers to cap.
- Scheelite can carry significantly more molybdenum. The USGS notes that molybdenum can substitute in scheelite at up to about 2%, against about 0.1% in wolframite. APT producers prefer low-molybdenum concentrate, because molybdenum has to be removed during refining. Scheelite concentrates can also carry phosphorus and calcium-bearing gangue from the skarn.
None of these is unusual. The point is that the impurity schedule in a contract should match the mineral. A specification written for wolframite will not always cover the risks of a scheelite lot, and the reverse is also true.
Different routes to APT
At the converter, both minerals are decomposed chemically to dissolve the tungsten, which is then purified and crystallised as APT. The route differs:
- Wolframite is conventionally digested with sodium hydroxide (caustic soda) at elevated temperature and pressure.
- Scheelite is harder to break down. Caustic soda alone does not decompose it well under normal commercial conditions, so converters use soda ash in an autoclave at above 180 °C, or acid routes at elevated temperature.
Many converters can treat both, but each plant is designed and optimised around a particular feed. This is why the mineral type is part of the specification, not a detail. A converter may pay less for, or decline, a concentrate that does not suit its process, even at the same WO₃ grade.
Pricing: same unit, different discussions
Wolframite and scheelite are both quoted per MTU of WO₃, usually with reference to APT. In China's domestic market, price services quote 65% wolframite and 65% scheelite concentrate as separate products. Outside China, the price discussion between buyer and seller will reflect the mineral type, the impurity profile and the converter's process. Two lots of the same grade can therefore earn different deductions.
What buyers should check
- Mineral type: wolframite, scheelite or a mixed concentrate, and whether it suits your process or your converter's.
- WO₃ grade: on a dry basis, with the sampling and assay method stated.
- Impurity schedule: tin, arsenic, sulphur and copper for wolframite; molybdenum, phosphorus and calcium-bearing gangue for scheelite. Check limits and the deduction for each.
- Particle size: very fine concentrate from flotation or fines recovery can handle differently at the converter.
- Origin and traceability: vein-hosted wolframite from artisanal or small-scale production needs documented traceability to a verified mine site.
For specifications and grades available, see our tungsten page.
Sources
- USGS Circular 930-O: International Strategic Minerals Inventory summary report, Tungsten
- Han, Golev and Edraki (2021): A review of tungsten resources and potential extraction from mine waste, Minerals
- Msumange et al. (2023): Tungsten tailings issues and reprocessing solutions, Minerals and Mineral Materials
- MINING.COM: Trinity Metals doubles US tungsten concentrate supply to 20%
- Minor Metals Trade Association: APT metal norm and MTU definition
- Chinatungsten Online: Average prices of tungsten products in October 2026